Woodford Reserve Distiller’s Select Review

Whiskey Name: Woodford Reserve Distiller’s Select

Distillery: Woodford Reserve (and Brown-Forman Distillery)

Whiskey Type: Rye recipe bourbon

Release Date: Launched in 1996.

Price: (+/-) £30 

Age: NAS

ABV: 43.2% 

Mashbill: 72% corn, 18% rye, 10% malted barley

Introduction/Background: If it wasn’t for Woodford Reserve Distiller’s Select I wouldn’t be in the BBS. Back in my early University days it gave me my bourbon epiphany, and for a while after that it was the only bourbon I drank.

Brown-Forman repurchased their old Oscar Pepper site in the ‘90s, renamed it Woodford Reserve, launched Distiller’s Select in 1996, and the rest is history. These days you’ll find the DS on the shelves of every UK supermarket, normally priced at about £30 unless it’s on offer. It’s a blend of pot still bourbon from the Woodford Reserve distillery and column still bourbon from the Brown-Forman distillery.

Ubiquitous, sure, but I haven’t tried it in ages outside of a cocktail, so I thought I’d use it to kick the month off.

Appearance: Medium shade of Mahogany. On the darker end of the supermarket bourbon spectrum.

Nose: Char. Quite deep; there’s a rather fruity aspect as well; oranges perhaps, plus ripe toffee apple. Some strawberry laces in the background. Slightly muted; the rye, in particular, isn’t really singing. It’s a little muddled and musty – not as clear and clean as the likes of Bulleit.

Mouth: A step up. Fruitcakey, and surprisingly plump considering the low proof. There’s a little rye-led nutmeg, though this is more about the deeper flavours; dark chocolate and caramel. Still lacks a little clarity and definition; the flavours seem to be working against each other at times. There also isn’t much cutting through them, which flattens it a little. Perhaps not surprising given the proof.

Finish: The sweeter, deeper flavours dissipate into a dry oakiness.

Value for Money: About right. Just.

Summary: Always nice to return to an old favourite, albeit tempered by the context of having tried hundreds of others since being away. Still a decent pour, with the caveat that a couple of muddled elements distract from the whole, and there isn’t really any ‘wow factor’. That said, its deep fruit and chocolate offer a different flavour profile to other bourbons you’ll find on supermarket shelves, and are perfectly tasty for the price. Personally I’d probably only buy it if it was on offer, but then I am very stingey.

Overall Verdict: Solid, if not spectacular, but offers enough point of difference to retain relevance.

Review by WhiskyPilgrim